⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ (Five Stars)

Now playing at the Apollo Theatre following highly acclaimed runs at Nottingham Playhouse and the Young Vic, Punch is an example of theatre at its most powerful. James Graham’s masterful writing brings sensitivity and humanity to the true story of Jacob Dunne, a young man who, with a single punch, permanently changed both the Hodgkinson family and his own life. What could have been a straightforward retelling of tragedy instead becomes a hopeful exploration of accountability, forgiveness, and the redemptive power of empathy and kindness.

The first act of the play centres on Jacob (played excellently by David Shields) as he recounts the fateful night in Nottingham in 2011 when his unprovoked attack resulted in the death of James Hodgkinson. His narration is interwoven with flashbacks from his childhood and the shattering grief of James’ parents as they come to terms with their son’s injury and subsequent passing. The second act shifts focus to Jacob’s life after prison and the deeply moving restorative justice process he embarks on with James’ parents, culminating in them working together to raise awareness for the fatal consequences of a single punch and the transformative power of restorative justice.

David Shields is captivating in his performance, bringing remarkable authenticity to Jacob’s story. Alongside him, the small ensemble cast demonstrate great versatility, taking on multiple roles throughout the play. Julie Hesmondhalgh and Tony Hirst are devastating as James’ bereaved parents, embodying both the unimaginable grief and the extraordinary strength to carry forward their son’s legacy of kindness and empathy towards his killer.

Anna Fleischle’s set design features two ramps leading to a bridge above the main playing space, adding dynamic levels for the action, while images of the Meadows estate in Nottingham where Jacob grew up cover the stage floor, grounding his story in place throughout. Robbie Butler’s lighting design deepens this connection, at times illuminating the windows of this ever-present backdrop of Jacob’s home and upbringing. Butler’s work also powerfully shapes atmosphere and setting, such as during moments of chaos and violence and in the prison scenes where stark lighting conveys the bleakness and isolation.

Directed with clarity and compassion by Adam Penford, Punch is essential viewing. It is a profoundly moving production that highlights the possibility of healing and change even in the wake of unthinkable tragedy.

Punch runs at Apollo Theatre until 29th November 2025.

Tickets Available Here